Your comparison is nice and the numbers are clear. For preference I'll go with the Snow-tombed star silver. It out damages the prototype type in some instances and it's passive has a much shorter cool down. Thanks for helping me make my choice.
Nice comparison, however there is mistake in your final picture on elemental skill damage for snow-tombed. you did 3.4k and 5.1k on snow-tombed but you listed 3.9k and 9.7k in the final comparison picture.
Pasif efek crit damage nya jauh banget bang parah, gua mau bikin second team dan dps nya razor pake snow tombed nah enak nya dipasangin sama siapa support nya???
Even during ult, Razor has higher dps when he is auto-attacking, canceling, and not using his skill even in ult. This is because a physical built Razor is profiting off of his physical damage, not his electro damage. If you don't believe me: https://youtu.be/yOKX50nGuVM?t=478
So it's clear to me that both builds are viable. A proper Snow-Tombed build is doubling down on physical. I would invest in the Snow-Tombed if you are going for a physical build, and I would invest in the Prototype Archaic if you are going for an electro build.
Personally I will be going with electro Archaic because I like to use my skills and swap to different characters a bit more often than most people do, that's more my playstyle. But people should not underestimate the importance of a full physical Razor build if that's what you want.
Your prototype is refinement 2, so it deals 300% dmg instead of the (r1) 240% dmg! Just correcting the fact. I still think Aminus (I'm not gonna call it Archaic, I like the name Aminus) is the overall better weapon between the two! I prefer refining Aminus over Snowtombed Starsilver. 😀
punya ku kasih ke xingyan
Wait, prototype sub statnya ganti ?
Bukannya dulu physcal dmg ya ? Kok sekarang atk %
u need to test it with a cryo support (not chongyun) qiqi or kaeya will do 🙂
should i refine prototype archaic=lvl3 or snow-tombed silver= lvl 2?
is this weapon still good without a cryo in your team?
It’s hard since you have to take into account the superconduct that it applies
Just what I needed, a quick comparison video. Thanks!
Wonder why they change the name
Your comparison is nice and the numbers are clear. For preference I'll go with the Snow-tombed star silver. It out damages the prototype type in some instances and it's passive has a much shorter cool down. Thanks for helping me make my choice.
how to get this weapon?
Imo animus Deals more burst DMG but starsilver is more Consistant
Nice comparison, however there is mistake in your final picture on elemental skill damage for snow-tombed. you did 3.4k and 5.1k on snow-tombed but you listed 3.9k and 9.7k in the final comparison picture.
Do you have a physical dmg cup ?
what should i use for noelle?
You wrote the wrong number in elemental skill
Snow-Tombed Starsilve
Elemental skill: 3498
Critical damage: 7993
Elemental skill (hold): 5184
Crit damage: 11845
Prototype
Elemental skill: 3881
Critical damage: 8867
Elemental skill (hold): 5751
Crit damage: 13141
Just saying but it's impossibile that physical damage can boost electro damage of Razor E lol, also prototype still better than snow claymore
Pasif efek crit damage nya jauh banget bang parah, gua mau bikin second team dan dps nya razor pake snow tombed nah enak nya dipasangin sama siapa support nya???
I don't know what difference it makes but the protoype is a refinement 2
Even during ult, Razor has higher dps when he is auto-attacking, canceling, and not using his skill even in ult. This is because a physical built Razor is profiting off of his physical damage, not his electro damage. If you don't believe me: https://youtu.be/yOKX50nGuVM?t=478
So it's clear to me that both builds are viable. A proper Snow-Tombed build is doubling down on physical. I would invest in the Snow-Tombed if you are going for a physical build, and I would invest in the Prototype Archaic if you are going for an electro build.
Personally I will be going with electro Archaic because I like to use my skills and swap to different characters a bit more often than most people do, that's more my playstyle. But people should not underestimate the importance of a full physical Razor build if that's what you want.
Prototype wins , even if its R1 , its still better
So, Snow-Tombed bad. Got it.
Try with both weapons refinement rank 5
the refinement is not balance, also you didn't show the bonus damage number on snow-tomb to enemy that afflicted with cryo.
you're lacking cryo damage bonus from the weapon
should've added kaeya for this video, so people know the full potential of that new weapon
Doesn't seem fair because Prototype Archaic is on refinement 2
If i do the the math i will go for R1 Aminus
u didint use the dmg when they r afected by cryo debuff :O
I think the everfrost icicle should give enemy frost debuff that what i thought it would do before the release it would make the weapon so much better
Your prototype is refinement 2, so it deals 300% dmg instead of the (r1) 240% dmg!
Just correcting the fact. I still think Aminus (I'm not gonna call it Archaic, I like the name Aminus) is the overall better weapon between the two! I prefer refining Aminus over Snowtombed Starsilver. 😀
prototype vs serpant ?
This weapon good for diluc?