Genshin Impact (PC / PS4 Pro) โ Barbara Old vs New Voice Comparison after Patch 1.3
#GenshinImpact #Endgame #Barbara
Gameplay Raw footage edited in a synthetic manner for information purposes. All Gameplay played, recorded & edited by me.
Credits for the meme to Markiplier
join our discord community & discuss your favourite games with us: https://discordapp.com/invite/w4EbJgk
twitter: https://twitter.com/TotallyNotMeloo
About Meloo:
Meloo is a channel that produces Guides, Creative Edits, High Quality Lore Videos, Comparisons & Mods for new video game releases. In my videos I draw parallels, use Juxtapositions and other editing techniques to deliver my Gameplay in a transformative manner from the original narrative rather than full letโs plays. I usually focus on games for a more mature audience. All Gameplay is my own and is recorded and edited by me.
Source
Barbara Depressed edition
both are shit anyways imo lol
the new voice is better, fight me
No self respecting gamer uses english voices.
just set japanese voices, that's better.
I don't think she sounds sad, she just sounds sad when compared to her old voice. Doesn't matter to me cuz I prefer the JP voices ๐คฃ
Barbruh
She's depressed lmao
I'm still questioning…why?!
Her tragic demise reminds me of Britney Spears. What happens with 1.4 – Barbara shaves her head and gets checked into a mental hospital !?!?
Prefer japanese Va
apparently its the same voice actor but the directer decided to use different voice lines
noooooo babara happy voice was only thing keeping me alive
Not the [Redacted] green screen video ๐ญ๐ญ๐ญ
Barbara sounds like she is whispering.
Didn't know Markplier plays Genshin Impact
Sounds so much better new. Thankfully they didn't change the other language voice actors, they sound much better than English old or new.
Now Barbara sonuds like a female version of Max Payne
tf the new voice is better for barbara
please do not hate on the voice actor for it
she's depressed now ๐
In my opinion I personally think this one represents her as a character better. First of all, the cutscenes already were in this style to begin with and the old voice clips were going to be replaced due to the fact they were added in the beta and no longer reflected who she was deep done and even just in the cutscenes. She really isn't a idol as much as she is a church girl and has always been shy and quiet due to her developing an inferiority complex from Jean because of how successful she is compared to Barbara. Though I understand now liking the voice as much I believe that this represents better the person she is and not the character you want her to be. It's possible that she will be more energetic in the future but right now she is still struggling to overcome her inferiority complex so it makes sense that her voice lines during game play reflect that. She has not overcome her obstacles yet and I think that leaves room for character development that we, the player can actually see instead of just simply in her friendship locked dialogue. It's important to remember that her friend ship dialogue and cutscene dialogue did not go with her gameplay voice clips and it creates a weird contrast story wise. But at the end of the day people seem to base it simply on what they like hearing rather than what actually would match her personality. It equaly important not to use her gameplay voice clips as the measure for her personality when there are plenty more sources for that in game.
Okay Iโll ask.
Whatโs the link for that markiplier edit? ๐๐๐๐
in Japanese is better anyway so it makes no difference
Unpopular opinion: I like Barbara's new voice change the old one was too raspy.
English voice ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ๐คฎ
I liked the raspy strained sound in the OG voice, does that make sense? Seemed more enthusiastic as everyone says.
this controversy is the reason i use JAPANESE dub
A mix of the old voice enthusiasm and the new voice smoothness would be good though (to make it similar to other langage dub)
The new voice sound more like a idol and Barbara is a idol
I like her new voice ๐
the one that i hate the most is when she says
go barbara go.
IDK why, but it feels like
supermythicmhyticallySkyGodtierSrank
AWFUL
Wow. Didn't know this. I'm always into japanese dub anyways. So, I don't really care. But new one is much better for me. Idols don't have raspy voice.
I don't know but the new voice is kinda cringey
People actually crying about her voice. ๐
I understand what Mihoyo wanted to make Barbara sounds like a shy cute idol. If you watch one of the 1.3 video, Barbara sounds very shy. But now her voice is not only shy but straight up depressed
Personally, I prefer the old voice. However, please donโt go and attack the VA for this like some people are. Laura Stahl did absolutely nothing. So to the people doing that, please please please stop.
I have a feeling that she'll be getting her own story where she's all depressed and wants to die and we swoop in to save her from the dark and to wake her up
wake her up inside
Can't related I use Japan VA๐
Sooo… you're bitching about a garbage character's change of voice.
If you don't like it, I'd say to get over it.
Your opinion doesn't matters to anyone, and hunting down the current VA won't change a thing.
The old voice is kinda raspy and not cute at all. As somebody who has not heard either voice before this, because I've only used the Chinese and Japanese voices, I can say the new voice is better.
No hate, just meming on it
Wait why does she sound different?
I really like Her New Voice its Calm! You can Cry or hate the New voice but for me Genuinely its Perfect!